File photo of snow in Cincinnati Flickr Creative Commons User Jerekeys
Hide Caption

Best & worst driveway ice melters

Don't Waste Your Money

a a a a
Share this story

With wintry weather hitting the Tri-State again, many people are wondering which driveway ice melters are most effective, and whether windshield de-icers really work.

We Put Melters to the Test

I have done several tests over the years, comparing different types of ice melter on the same snowy and icy sidewalk, with the same results each time.

This is one case where products claiming they are "tough"really do live up to their claims. 

The problem is that salt, which is cheap and fairly effective, loses its effectiveness once the temperature drops much below 20 degrees.  And that's where you really need it.

The Winner is....

So based on results of three separate "Don't Waste Your Money" comparisons in the past 5 years, here is what we found.
 

  • 1st Place: Chemical Pellets ("Prestone Driveway Heat," "Fire and Ice," others)
  •  
  • 2nd Place: Environmentally Safe Melters ("Safe Step," others)
  •  
  • 3rd Place: Rock Salt, a great value, but simply not effective below 15 degrees


This is why road crews add calcium chloride to the salt they spread on roads.  Many of the chemical pellets contain calcium chloride or similar additives.

Which Can Ruin Your Sidewalk?

You might think chemical melters might be hazardous to your side walk, but most of them are safe for concrete and asphalt. 
 
It's actually rocks alt that causes the most harm to concrete and metal.

If you are concerned about plants and your lawn, however, the environmentally friendly melters are the way to go. 
 
They break down, causing no damage to plants or animals, and in many cases will work down to zero degrees.

Windshield Ice Melters
 
I have done a separate test of windshield ice melters. CLICK HERE to read those results.
 
As always, don't waste your money.
______________________
 
Dont Waste Your Money is a registered trademark of the EW Scripps Co.
 
Follow John on Twitter @DWYM
I

 

Copyright 2013 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Print this article

Comments

Hmm... It looks like you’re not a WCPO Insider. or Subscribe now to contribute!

More DWYM
Last minute deals on Easter candy, clothing
Last minute deals on Easter candy, clothing

John Matarese has some great last minute Easter deals.

Angie's List: Doing your home warranty homework
Angie's List: Doing your home warranty homework

Don't sign up for a home warranty until you do your homework.

Secrets to avoid the soaring price of beef
Secrets to avoid the soaring price of beef

John Matarese has ways of avoiding soaring steak prices

When it's safe to shred old documents
When it's safe to shred old documents

John Matarese shows what's safe to shred, and which papers you should save forever.

Cars that can last 200,000 miles
Cars that can last 200,000 miles

John Matarese reports on cars that run for years and years.

Scammers using Netflix to steal from millions
Scammers using Netflix to steal from millions

A dangerous new phishing scam is targeting the sensitive information of millions of Netflix users.

More products shrinking for 2014
More products shrinking for 2014

John Matarese shows the latest products getting smaller at the store

Cobalt, Saturn owners anxious for repair
Cobalt, Saturn owners anxious for repair

John Matarese reports on the wait for ignition switch repairs

Swifty gas station closings mean end of an era
Swifty gas station closings mean end of an era

John Matarese reports on the end of full-service gasoline.

iPhone 6 plans leaked: Bigger, thinner
iPhone 6 plans leaked: Bigger, thinner

John Matarese has a preview of Apple's upcoming new iPhone.