File photo Creative Commons
Hide Caption

Tri-State couple's credit report nightmare

Don't Waste Your Money

a a a a
Share this story

One in five people find mistakes on their credit report every year.

And while you may think you can just call up and get something wrong removed from your credit report, it's not that simple.

In fact, a growing number of people are saying it can be impossible to get those errors corrected.

Thought They Had Good Credit Until...

Dick and Gayle Collier of Madeira, Ohio say they took their good credit for granted.

"You're totally embarrassed," Dick said. "It hits on your ego. I mean, you work all your life, you save and you're careful and then all of a sudden, no credit. We can't get accepted for a car loan. It just really messes with your head."

Five years ago, the Colliers started seeing big mistakes on their credit reports. They thought it would be easy to correct them.

Gayle's records are meticulous. She keeps binders, spread sheets and subscribes to a credit reporting service.

Keeping track of her and her husband's credit reports is like a full time job, she said.

Hard To Correct Errors

"You will hear, 'that's easy to do, to simply write a dispute letter,'" an exasperated Gayle Collier said.

TransUnion, one of the "big 3" credit bureaus, tells you the same thing. They even have an online video to tell you exactly how to dispute an error.

Federal law mandates all credit reporting agencies investigate any dispute.

But critics said the investigation often goes nowhere.

Ohio Attorney General Mike DeWine is one of those critics.

"It's a joke, the investigation that they do," DeWine said.

DeWine, and other attorneys generals across the country, say they have started a large-scale investigation into credit report errors that plague millions of consumers.

"This is a system that works real well for everybody but the consumer," DeWine said.

Where Things Go Wrong

What's the problem? DeWine said if you find an error, you are supposed to send a dispute letter with documentation.

But he said the system breaks down from there.

The documentation doesn't get sent directly to creditors, he said, instead it goes to third party companies outside the country, where agents sometimes have to look at 90 complaints or more a day.

DeWine said he has seen cases dragged on for several years without resolution.

We were unable to speak with anyone with Experian, Equifax, and TransUnion to discuss DeWine's charges. A lobbying group for the credit reporting agencies, meantime, would not confirm the Attorneys General investigation.

And the lobbying group would not comment for our report.

But DeWine is not backing down from his criticism of the industry.

"We've had people who can't buy a house or car," DeWine said. "And they keep telling the reporting agency what the facts are and they keep getting jerked around."

It hasn't worked well for the Colliers.

They had to turn to DeWine's office for help. Finally, the mistakes were fixed -- or so they thought.

"Within six weeks of those changes," Gayle Collier said, "it changed right back."

She does not know who put the incorrect information back on her credit report. So the fight continues.

How to Protect Yourself

Here are some things you should do, according to DeWine:

- Check your credit report with the 3 credit bureaus every year: It's free at .

- As soon as you find an error, start writing letters to get it corrected. You'll want that mistake gone next time you apply for a loan.

- Check out the official attorney general website for links and facts that can help you.

- If you get nowhere in two months, contact your State Attorney General's office and ask for their help.

In Ohio, call 800-282-0515.

In Kentucky, call 1-888-432-9257.

In Indiana, call 1-800-382-5516.

And that way, you don't waste your money.


Don't Waste Your Money is a registered trademark of the EW Scripps Co.

"Like" John Matarese on Facebook

Follow John on Twitter (@JohnMatarese)

Copyright 2014 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Print this article


Hmm... It looks like you’re not a WCPO Insider. or Subscribe now to contribute!

Cobalt, Saturn owners anxious for repair
Cobalt, Saturn owners anxious for repair

John Matarese reports on the wait for ignition switch repairs

Scammers using Netflix to steal from millions
Scammers using Netflix to steal from millions

A dangerous new phishing scam is targeting the sensitive information of millions of Netflix users.

Prom or bridal dress shopping online? Beware
Prom or bridal dress shopping online? Beware

John Matarese has a caution for anyone trying to save money by dress shopping onlin.e

App of the Week
App of the Week

Check out John Matarese's latest money saving smartphone apps.

IRS phone scam targeting thousands
IRS phone scam targeting thousands

John Matarese has a warning about a major tax scam this spring.

How much water is in the chicken you buy?
How much water is in the chicken you buy?

When it comes to chicken, big packs of boneless breasts look like a good deal. But look closer.

Gasoline, beef prices soaring
Gasoline, beef prices soaring

John Matarese looks into higher prices hitting just as spring arrives

"One Ring" phone scam getting worse

John Matarese warns about the "One-Ring" scam

Easy tax mistakes that could get you audited
Easy tax mistakes that could get you audited

As millions of Americans race to meet Tuesday's tax deadline, they will make mistakes that could increase their chances of being put…

How to avoid worthless home warranties
How to avoid worthless home warranties

Every spring, thousands of Tri-State homeowners buy or renew home warranties to protect themselves against costly repairs. But are all…