File photo of a jail cell
Hide Caption

Jury needs 17 minutes to convict Indiana man of murdering mother's 75-year-old best friend

a a a a
Share this story

NEW ALBANY, Ind. (AP) -- A jury that took less than 20 minutes Friday to find a southern Indiana man guilty of murder in the death of his late mother's 75-year-old best friend will now decide whether he should face the death penalty.

The jury of eight women and four men was out 17 minutes Friday afternoon before announcing it had found William Clyde Gibson guilty of murder in the death of 75-year-old Christine Whitis, The Courier-Journal of Louisville, Ky., reported (HTTP://CJKY.IT/17JMVXO ). Prosecutors say he lured Whitis to his New Albany home to perform "a perverse sexual fantasy."

Floyd County Prosecutor Keith Henderson said after the guilty verdict was announced that he's confident jurors will sentence Gibson to death when they convene Monday for the sentencing phase.

"I think the evidence is there," he said.

Defense attorneys have said they won't comment until the trial is over.

Henderson said Whitis' slaying is probably the most disturbing he's ever seen, saying he tried to minimize the gruesome details, including some information about the body mutilation. "So even with the minimal amount that was presented, very disturbing, very gruesome, very difficult," he said.

Henderson said Gibson continued to assault the body even after Whitis was dead.

Gibson also is accused of strangling a 35-year-old Stephanie Kirk, whose remains were found buried in his backyard last year days after his arrest, and in the 2002 stabbing death of Karen Hodella, 44, of Port Orange, Fla. He's to be tried separately in those slayings and also faces the death penalty in Kirk's death.

Before closing arguments Friday, the defense recalled one prosecution witness and called no new witnesses.

The jury of eight women and four men was brought in from Dearborn County, about 100 miles northeast of New Albany, because of extensive media coverage.

---

Information from: The Courier-Journal, HTTP://WWW.COURIER-JOURNAL.COM

Copyright 2013 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Print this article

Comments

Hmm... It looks like you’re not a WCPO Insider. or Subscribe now to contribute!

More Crime & Justice
High-speed police chase ends in man's bedroom
High-speed police chase ends in man's bedroom

A high-speed police chase began on I-275, after a man stole a car from Dayton, Ky., and drove to Union Township, crashing into the bedroom of…

Campus sexual assault: UC fights on three fronts
Campus sexual assault: UC fights on three fronts

This time of year, high school seniors are deciding where to go to college. For many young women and their parents, the issue of campus…

2 arrested after gun fired in Brown Co. home
2 arrested after gun fired in Brown Co. home

A man called authorities from a Brown County home Friday to report another man shooting a gun under the same roof, and both men were arrested.

Petition filed to oust Brown County coroner
Petition filed to oust Brown County coroner

A petition filed Wednesday could push Brown County's coroner out of the job.

Westwood man charged in rape of 6-year-old
Westwood man charged in rape of 6-year-old

A Westwood man was arrested Monday and charged in the rape of a 6-year-old.

Campus sexual assault: NKU's prevention strategy
Campus sexual assault: NKU's prevention strategy

This time of year, high school seniors are deciding where to go to college. For many young women and their parents, the issue of campus…

Mayor Cranley: 'Help is on the way'
Mayor Cranley: 'Help is on the way'

Cincinnati Mayor John Cranley says he's making good on his promise to add more cops to the streets.

Man pleads not guilty after 49 horses found dead
Man pleads not guilty after 49 horses found dead

A Northern Kentucky man charged with 15 counts of animal cruelty and 49 counts of failing to dispose of carcasses after officers found 49…

Family of murdered mom, daughter seek closure
Family of murdered mom, daughter seek closure

A jury reached a verdict of guilty Tuesday afternoon in the trial of an East Price Hill man charged with the 2012 stabbing deaths of a mother…

Former PNC vice president receives 3 yr sentence
Former PNC vice president receives 3 yr sentence

A former PNC vice president who pleaded guilty to robbing a Key Bank in Anderson Township to sustain his cocaine addiction was sentenced to 3…